Rhonda Eudaly

Red and white banner saying Scam Alert

Predators have been trying to scam writers and artists since the dawn of time. I’m sure on some cave painting there’s a line of figures saying how Grog can make TukTuk famous for his mastodon painting skills for the low low price of one tusk.

Dark and light rock from painted desert with ancient carvings in it.

This rock was from the Painted Desert National Park. It has ancient narrative images in it. Once I realized what I was looking at, chills. This was the beginning of narrative art. Of non-verbal storytelling. It was and is awe inspiring.

Those scams have gotten bolder and sneakier with the advent of technology and AI. Some are obvious from the jump – bad grammar or “off” sounding word choices, misspellings, etc. But some you have to look a whole lot closer. You almost have to be a cyber detective – or at least caffeinated enough to find the signs.

What are the signs?

  1. Unsolicited emails. If you didn’t ask someone to reach out to you, be wary.
  2. Does it sound too good to be true? Scam.
  3. Does anything about it make you itch? Trust that feeling.

Why am I bringing this up today? Obviously, I just got hit with one. And I’m naming names. Because this one is BOLD. It mentions a Big Five Publisher. Claims to BE a Big Five Publisher Imprint. (Yes, I will report it). Might draw someone in…until… it ticks those three warning signs and you read the email address. Because my pretties, the BIGGEST, BADDEST Red Flag of them all… a Gmail or Yahoo or HOLY 1990s Batman an AOL email address.

From Eric Nelson
eric_nelson_harpercollins@aol.com

Dear Rhonda,

I hope this message finds you well.
My name is Eric Nelson, and I am Vice President and Publisher of Broadside Books, an imprint of HarperCollins Publishers.

I recently came across your collection, The Astronaut Stole My Sharpie and Other Stories, and wanted to reach out personally. What caught my attention was the intriguing title and the imaginative range of storytelling behind the collection.

I find the combination of science fiction, fantasy, murder, conspiracies, and humor particularly interesting. Bringing together different genres in a short-story collection requires creativity and an ability to keep readers curious. I also appreciate how your work embraces unusual ideas and unexpected adventures rather than remaining confined to one storytelling formula.

I would be interested in learning more about your journey as a writer, the inspiration behind this collection, and your broader vision for your literary work.

I would also like to ask whether you currently have a publishing representative or an existing publishing arrangement, and whether you would be open to exploring additional publishing opportunities for your work.

At Broadside Books, we focus primarily on political, cultural, and current-affairs nonfiction. Your collection falls outside our usual publishing categories, so I would want to be transparent about that rather than imply an established editorial fit. Nevertheless, I would welcome the opportunity to learn more about your work and discuss whether there might be an appropriate publishing avenue.

Would you like me to share some information about our publishing process, compensation, and royalty structure so you can better understand how a potential publishing arrangement could work?

Thank you for your time, Rhonda. I would be pleased to hear more about your writing, your publishing experiences, and what you hope to accomplish with your future books.
Warm regards,

Eric Nelson
Vice President and Publisher
Broadside Books | HarperCollins Publishers

Seriously? And AOL address. Keep your eyes open, my friends. Because though I WOULD be interested in (and am) exploring additional publishing representation and opportunities, it’s not going to be here. This is why you’ll hear all of us talk about the “right way” to approach publishers and editors. About building relationships and doing the work, because there’s too much of this crap in the world.

So keep an eye on your email. Hold on to your dreams. Not ALL of them are this easy to pick out – and even very experienced writers can have an off day and fall for this. If you’re suspicious, ask on social media or someone you trust. We’re all looking out for each other.

No responses yet

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Latest Comments